Thursday, October 11, 2012

Add One Part Dystopian, One Part Fantasy and a pinch of Steampunk, Blend Well...Looking at Genre Blending in YA Lit

Image Source


YALSA's (Young Adult Library Services Association) The Hub has featured some really interesting conversation topics this month as it it readies for Teen Read Week which begins on October 17. I love The Hub's website by the way. Their regular feature "The Next Big Thing..." is always an informative and entertaining look at predicted trends in YA literature. This month The Hub is running 31 Days of The Next Big Thing, gearing up for the YA Literature Symposium in St. Louis, November 2-4. Among others, topics this month have included Adults Reading YA, Social Reading, as well what's next for Fantasy, Steampunk and Science Fiction. 

But a recent topic that really caught my eye was entitled Wait-What IS This book, Anyway? Genre Blending in YA Lit. Because I read YA almost exclusively, I have noticed that there is a trend in the releases I have recently encountered. Lately many of the books that I have read don't easily fall under one genre category. Genres, like dystopian/ post apocalyptic, historical fiction, contemporary/ realistic, steampunk, science fiction, paranormal/supernatural, paranormal romance, horror, mystery and suspense/thriller are classifications that describe works of fiction. For booksellers and librarians these categories help readers find books that interest them.

But whereas The Hunger Games (Suzanne Collins), Divergent (Veronica Roth) and Delirium (Lauren Oliver) can be described as dystopian fiction, and The Girl of Fire and Thorns (Rae Carson), Graceling (Kristin Cashore), and Finnikin of the Rock (Melina Marchetta) can be described as fantasy fiction, there are a variety of other books out that defy simple categorization.


Take, for instance, Defiance by C.J. Redwine. The story of a teenage girl living in a walled city where women have few civil rights afforded to them since the world was ravaged and partially destroyed by dragon-like creatures that emerged from the bowels of the earth, hosts a number of different genres. That's a work best described as dystopic/ post apocalyptic/ fantasy because all three genres are included. 
What about Libba Bray's recent release The Diviners? That is a work of supernatural (ghosts and spirits)/ paranormal (the occult and magical abilities) historical fiction (takes place in the 1920's) with aspects of horror and mystery involved. 

Once you start thinking in these terms, you can see examples of genre mash-ups everywhere. Cinder (Marissa Meyer) is a fairy tale retelling featuring both science fiction and steampunk elements. Dearly, Departed (Lia Habel) is a blending of dystopic/post apocalyptic/ paranormal/ steampunk. I'm reading Black City by Elizabeth Richards and it's paranormal/ paranormal romance/ dystopic/ post apocalyptic with a bit of science fiction interspersed. 

Carla Land's above referenced article for The Hub notes that although it can be challenging for librarians and book stores to find the proper shelf for these books, it is an exciting time in YA lit nonetheless. Exciting because a book like The Infernal Devices (Cassandra Clare), which is historical fiction/ urban fantasy/ paranormal/ steampunk, has the ability to branch out and interest an even broader readership. 


The Vampire Empire Series is an excellent example of genre blending. Not only does it have elements that would appeal to vampire (paranormal-supernatural) fans, but it is also features an alternate history storyline (an off shoot or sub genre of historical fiction) and has a strong steampunk element as well. In addition this adult series has been shown to have wide crossover appeal with YA readers thus opening it's readership up to an even larger audience.

Of course genre blending is not exclusive to YA lit, I can think of examples in adult fiction as well, particularly with authors like Alice Hoffman (Practical Magic, The River King) and Sarah Addison Allen (Garden Spells, The Peach Keeper) who blend contemporary realistic story lines with magical realism, but many sources indicate that YA exhibits more of these mash ups than adult fiction, which is exciting in itself. With YA being bashed left and right among critics and authors alike, it's refreshing to read something positive. And I do think it's positive and exciting. I would be hard pressed to pick a favorite genre in the fiction I read, there are things I love about each of them. But this new blending of genres lets me have my cake and eat it too. And, being a girl who likes her cake, this is a good thing:)

What do you think about this new trend of genre mash-ups in current YA literature? Do you like it or do you prefer to to read books that are strictly of one genre? Do you think this trend is something we will see more of in the future,  or do you think it is a passing fad? Do you think that more authors, especially authors of adult fiction, will soon follow suit?  I'd love to hear your thoughts on this and examples of your favorite genre blended YA books in the comment section below:)

19 comments:

  1. Really great post! When I realized Defiance wasn't JUST fantasy, it totally made my day. I love all the mash-ups that are coming out, how different genres are able to weave together to create a completely new genre. I think it's a great trend and hope to see much more of it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Me too!extra genres feels like a bonus to me! Thanks for dropping by and commenting!

      Delete
  2. This is a really fun topic! I ALWAYS have trouble figuring out what category the book I'm reading fits into. And I've also realized that I like to read across a variety of genres, because it's the stories that I care about. So I love that authors are mashing things up. Also, books in one genre sometimes exhibit a type of sameness that they just can't help. But with mixing up elements they become fresh again. I haven't been checking out that website, so thanks for recommending it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I totally agree! It can start to feel routine when you are reading stories that fit within the framework of just one genre, case in point: DYSTOPIAN reads. And vampires, that's another. But through a vampire into a dystopian/ post apocalyptic/ science fiction book with time travel and that would be something I'd definitely check out!

      Delete
  3. I loveee the concept of genre-blending! I hated it in Defiance, simply because Defiance lacked world-building, making it have so many genres because you didn't know anything about the world, so that was more author-mistake-in-writing than genre-blending to me, but I've adored it in other books like The Diviners and especially The Dark Light by Sara Walsh. I think it opens up a tonn of new ideas, especially since standard dystopian is getting SO overdone these days, so I'm excited to see what new ideas stem up with these mixture of genres. Awesome post, Heather! :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes! You and Lauren echo the same sentiments, Keertana! Blending genres does open up room for more experimentation and the possibility of some truly original stories!

      Your comment reminds me how much I want to read The Dark Light! Must get that book soon:)

      Delete
  4. This is a totally fun post, Heather! I love the idea of genre blending, but unfortunately, I feel like it only works out every so often. Half of the time is comes across as a jumbled train wreck to me that makes me feel like the author couldn't really decide what they were doing so just threw everything in. One I read that I liked this year was the MG The Prince Who Fell From the Sky. It had fantasy elements (talking animals), but also sci fi (post-apocalyptic/space travel).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I haven't heard of that book, Heidi. I'll have to check it out.

      I agree that having more than one genre can lead to a cluttered plot but I still really like the experimentation and creativity that comes out of blending more than one genre:)

      As a librarian do you find it difficult to classify many of the YA and MG books being published today that cross genres? I wonder how your younger readers feel about it?

      Delete
  5. I am commenting all the time how I am loving these books that blend all the different genres. Some of them have ended up being some of my favorite reads for the year like Stormdancer. I love seeing all these concepts coming together and giving us something new and different all the time. Great, informative post, Heather :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I couldn't agree more, Heidi! I think that this is something that will be sticking around and not going away anytime soon.

      I keep starting Stormdancer only to be pulled away because a review book comes in. I want to take my time with it though because it seems to me to be the type book that deserves all your attention as you are reading it:)

      I'm curious, how would you describe Stormdancer, in terms of genre blending? Fantasy for sure, but what else?

      Delete
  6. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Fantastic post, Heather! I love mash ups because some of the best books come out as a result of thinking outside the box. It is very exciting time for any type of literature, the most unexpected books become bestsellers and show the publishers that to take on the unknown element can pay off hugely. That way not only authors win but us, readers, benefit hugely :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes! I love the creativity that comes with this kind of experimentation! It's so easy to feel like you have read it all before when sticking with pure fantasy or pure dystopian. But mash-ups, when done well, can really push the boundaries in terms of originality:)

      Delete
  8. I like anything that's DIFFERENT and genre blending is making that more possible. I think it took me awhile to warm up to it (especially dystopian/fantasy) but now I love it! I just read Black City and that was definitely different! But it was pretty cool!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Oh, fabulous post, Heather!! <3 Your post makes me rethink about all the books that I read. :) I agree, there are mash-up genres in YA right now. I really don't mind it since we have more flavors of books to taste (er... read?) now. :) I still love books with strict genres too though, since books with mash-up genres can be confusing sometimes LOL! :D

    ReplyDelete
  10. I love the trend -- I agree with what others above me have said: it makes a book more surprising, draws in more readers, and just feels more imaginative.

    But that is also why I don't list genres on my review summaries, because I'd have no idea what to call some of these books.

    ReplyDelete
  11. If it is does well..it is breathtaking and awesome like Mystic City and when its not eek. I love and hate this trend. It needs to be a solid blending and not a mere mention to label a book "steampunk, fantasy etc" for example Innocent Darkness..it fell apart and didn't blend.
    Awesome post!

    ReplyDelete

I would LOVE to hear your thoughts! Comments make my day and I really do read them all:)

**I have decided to change my settings, allowing only registered users to comment. I do this only because I am being inundated with spammy comments. I hope this is not a huge inconvenience to anyone:) **